My comments (23.01)
My comments (23.01)
My comment :
Ziral😂 은근슬쩍 넘어가려고 지ral을 해요. 그럼 성이 모고 씨가 김이라는 기록은 어떻게 해석함? 니가 원하는 기록만 쏙쏙 빼서 날조하고 이씨 입맛에 맞는 역사왜곡만 써넣네ㅋㅋ 역사학자 참 쉽네ㅋㅋㅋ 내가 해도 니보단 잘할듯ㅋ 주나라 귀족 이씨라면서 유전자는 왜 다름? 조상대대로 탁란 당하심? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 고대 신라인 이씨면 이것도 왜 유전자가 다름? 얘네도 탁란 당하심? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 니네는 CH 노예집단 후손에 역사날조로 이민 온 ZZangke들이야 😂😂😂 아 개웃겨ㅋㅋ
from: 당신의 ‘성씨’, ‘본관’, ‘족보’ 탄생에 대한 모든 진실 - 내가 알고 있던 것이 대부분 거짓?. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-09. Retrieved 2023-01-09.
Comment (夜行者):
Native Americans and Asians carry a version of the gene that is linked to thicker hair shafts, more sweat glands, and shovel-shaped incisors. A variant of this gene—V370A—arose about 30,000 years ago or so in China when the climate was hotter and more humid, which prompted researchers to speculate initially that it was advantageous to have more sweat glands in that environment. But the gene variant swept through the ancestors of Asians and Native Americans about 20,000 years ago The Mongols= East Asians, Austronesians, Altaic people (Turkic, Mongolic, and Tungusic speaking people), American Indians/Native Americans East Asians and Native Americans are Sinodont They carry the EDAR gene, found in ancient and modern East Asians, Southeast Asians, Nepalese and Native Americans but not common in African or European populations Inuit have 80% Q，Yenisei people 90%Q，Yakutia have 90%N，Korean have 80%O，North Tungusic have 80%C2 They were completely East Asian physical appearance： black hair and dark eyes. They also tend to have less body hair, less facial hair, flatter faces, smaller noses, wider cheekbones, and "shovel-shaped" incisor teeth (slightly scooped out shape of back side of the front teeth). 1，Modern Turks are Turkified Anatolians 2，Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, they look like Mongols, Koreans, Japanese, Yakuts Turkish doesn't look Asian at all 3，It is impossible for two Asian parents to have an white baby（Anatolians）！ 4，The Anatolians need a new identity after losing out the Ottoman Empire. They wanted to steal the whole steppe heritage of Eurasia created by Xiongnu, Rouran, Mongols and GokTurks to make them feel great again. About 50,000 years ago, C2D1 entered East Asia, and C1 entered Southeast AsiaAbout 40,000 years ago,K2 split into MNOPQRS entered East Asia and Siberia SM remained in Southeast Asia NO remained in East Asia PQR remained in Siberia About 30,000 years ago, QR separated About 20,000 years ago R went to Europe and Q went to America Therefore, Native Americans：Q1 C2 R1 As the climate began warming at around 18,000 years ago, the Beringia region also became more moist and the sea level rose,submerging the land bridge . About 10,000-15,000 years ago, N1O2 entered Mongolia and mixed with C2Q1R1 About 5000-10000 years ago Xiongnu/（C2 N1a O2a Q1）+ R1a→Xianbei → Rouran → Turkic Empire →Mongol Empire→ Qing Empire Mongolian=53,8%C2+10,8%O2+10,8%N1+4,6%P* (xQ,R)+9,2%R1a Ulch people 34.6%C2(xM48, M407) 34.6% C2b1a2 11.5% O2, 1.9% O1a,1.9% O1b 5.8%Q-M242 5.8%N-M231 Then，proto-Altaic people split into two groups N1a and O2a+C2 1，N1a enter Siberia，they became the Neo-Siberians and Northern tungus (absorb Paleo-Siberians Q1+C2) 2，O2a+C2 enter the Korean peninsula,where they assimilated the earlier inhabitants of the peninsula(O1b). During the Yayoi period, haplogroup O1b2+O2a started to arrive and spreaded to every region of Japan. Origin of Japanese: Jomon (D1a2+C1a1) + Korean peninsula /Yayoi (O2a+O1b2). Korean=42.1%O2a+3.1%O1a+ 12.9%C2+ 3.8 %N1+ 33.4%O1b + 1.8%Q1+2.5%D Janpanese= 15-20%O2a 3-8%C1+C2 3%N1 30-35%O1b 35-40%D 3，Historians believe that the Huns were not a single ethnicity but a confederation-like grouping of Siberian natives（N1a Q1 C2） and Indo-European tribes（R1aR1b，Old European（I ））. The Slavs, Hungarians, Finns are among their descendants. 4，The modern Turkic people are a mixture of Eurasian People. These includes Indo-Iranian and Indo-European tribes of Central Asia who becomes Turkic for 2000 years ago. "Origin of "Proto-Altaic" language=Turkic+Mongolic+Tungusic+Uralic+Koreanic+Japonic" R1 dominates Indo-European languages R1a dominant Slavs + Indo-Iranians (Pashtuns, Iranians, Indians) R1b dominant Western European Q dominates Native American，Inuit people, Yenisei people N dominates Urals and Yakutia O dominate Japanese Korean Chinese C2 dominates Mongolian Kazakh Tungusic
Comment (PAPAZA TAKLA ATTIRAN İMAM):
Altaic (/ælˈteɪ.ɪk/; sometimes also called Transeurasian)[Note 1] is a controversial proposed language family[1] that would include the Turkic, Mongolic and Tungusic language families and possibly also the Japonic and Koreanic languages.[2]: 73 Speakers of these languages are currently scattered over most of Asia north of 35° N and in some eastern parts of Europe, extending in longitude from Turkey to Japan.[3] The group is named after the Altai mountain range in the center of Asia. The hypothetical language family has long been rejected by most comparative linguists, although it continues to be supported by a small but stable scholarly minority.[2][4][5]
Comment (GeoNomad):
Thanks for the very informative comments. I plan to make East Asian-related videos in the future. Can I get more information about the DNA of East Asians?
Comment (夜行者):
@GeoNomad Genetic history of East Asians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_history_of_East_Asians
Comment (GeoNomad):
@夜行者 Thank you.
My comment :
@GeoNomad Don't believe this damn man. Claiming that O1b and O2a are Yayoi is a long history distortion of the Chinese people. That's because in Chinese history, books write "Chinese" in Yayoi. However, if you believe in all Chinese history books, every ethnic in asia are descendants of the Chinese O2a, the Huns R and the Tungus C, and even O1b and N. On the Korean Peninsula, the ratio of O2b increases as it goes northwest, and Q increases as it goes northeast. Its definately not ture, and don’t trust him.
My comment :
@GeoNomad What people misunderstand is that barbarian can conquer the Chinese nation as a nation, but at the same time, Chinese immigrants change their population ratio to the Chinese people. And, this is done through a lot of internal history fabrication in China. Every civilization that contact with Chinese civilization is recorded as a descendant of the Chinese. East Asia is not originally homogenous, but homogenized. (For example, the Huns fled west, cause of feeling terrible about Chinese historical fabrication and immigration) (Chinese historian intentionally write down Chunwei(淳維) the Chinese as ancestor of Huns) That's why Chinese are originaly racist, and why other Eastern people are sensitive to race.
My comment :
@夜行者 You claim that O2a is a Gojoseon, but the Gojoseon people are descendants of the Shang people of China and are a group of Haplo C2. This is confirmed through the genetic distribution of the family name group and region, which self-proclaimed descendants of real Gojoseon.(Chinese surnames like Lee and Chang are not Gojoseon people. These are the surnames that the Chinese things as they immigrate with historical distortions.) Also, there was always a death threat to ancient maritime activities, and only groups with blood-related and religious connections could use ships. The O2a group, which is not marine culture at all, cannot move with the O1b group of marine culture. The O2a group was hated anywhere in Asia and no one wanted to mix with them. Today, more than half of Japan's 20%of O2a is dominated by the Chinese Tang Dynasty's O-m117, indicating that O2a's migration to the Korean Peninsula and Japan is during the Tang Dynasty (7th-9th century). And the O2a group always distorted history like you are doing now.
Comment (夜行者):
This was written by a Korean In the case of East Asian Y-DNA, it was already mutated from NO to N, O2, O1, O1a, O1b1, O1b2, etc. from 30,000 years ago, during the Ice Age. The tribes could be viewed as being of the same genetic group. Each of these gene groups walked through Sundaland and moved to various places such as East Asia, Southeast Asia, and Siberia to settle there. The gene that arrived on the Korean Peninsula about 20,000 years ago was O1b2. As the Ice Age ended 10,000 years ago and the Neolithic Age began, sea levels rose due to the melting glacier and the Yellow Sea was created, and O1b2 was isolated on the Korean Peninsula. This theory is supported by recently excavated bones from Gadeokdo(가덕도, 加德島) in South Korea. They turned out to be 7000 years old, and were found to be O1b2. Around 2000 BC, O1b2a2 and O1b2a1 were mutated from O1b2 in south-east part of South Korea. Around 1000 BC, for some reason a part of the O1b2a1 group migrated to Japan (first Yayoi migration), where the population increased over hundreds of years. Around 200 BC, lots of Dongyi people from the north (Gojoseon, O2) migrated to southern part of K peninsula and founded a nation (Mahan). [Evidence: According to [後漢書], “King Jun of Joseon(Gojoseon) was defeated by Weiman, and led the remaining thousands of people through the sea, attacked Mahan, defeated Mahan, and established himself as the king of Han(韓).” According to [三國志], “With every dawn, many refugees flowed into Mahan's homeland, and Mahan was founded.”] Those migrated Dongyi (O2) mixed with the natives (O1b2). From that time, many peoples (O1b2 + O2) of K peninsula have begun to migrate to Japan (second Yayoi migration) until 660 AD when Baekjae was destroyed. Then, Qin migrants (O2) arrived in K peninsula and found a nation (Jinhan). [Evidence: According to [魏書 東夷傳, 後漢書], “Jinhan (辰韓) people were refugees from Qin (秦) to avoid hard labor (苦役), and Mahan allocated the eastern border (Jinhan).” According to [三國遺事], “辰韓(Jinhan) is also called 秦韓.”] Then, after AD, another northern Dongyi (Buyeo, O2 + C2) arrived in K peninsula and founded Goguryo and Baekje. [Evidence: According to [魏書 東夷傳], “Goguryeo was an another kind of Buyeo.” According to [後漢書], “Baekje was an another kind of Buyeo.”] That's why modern Koreans have O2(45%, Dongyi migrants from the north), O1b2(35% ~ 40%, natives), C(15%, migrants from the north). However, in Japan, the first Yayoi migrants were O1b2 and the second Yayoi migrants were (O1b2 + O2) (both from K peninsula). Thus, O1b2 population is two times higher than O2 (O2 arrived late on the K Peninsula). Yayoi migrants mixed with Jomon and became today’s Japanese.
Comment (夜行者):
Korean genetic marker is O1
You should to discuss O1, not O2,C2,Q,N,R1😂
My comment :
@夜行者 You wrote your delusion that O2a is a Yayoi immigrant in the fourth comment above this, and deleted it.
Didn't you delete the comments because you yourself know how delusional your writing is?
Also, I don't know how useless life is to write comments right away at dawn on weekdays. Your time value and my time value are not same.
And according to your C-ancient historical records, Jinhan is a refugee from the Qin Dynasty, but isn't it definitely a historical fabrication even though your Chinese people’s thinking?
Isn't it a historical fabrication that the Qin Dynasty group, which has a different language from Koreans&Chinese in the west of China, is used for labor in northeastern China with a lot of administrative effort? Why they do that?
This is the traditional way for the Chinese to destroy other countries/ethnic through historical distortions and immigration.
And the Qin Dynasty is not originaly Chinese.
Emperor Qin-Shi-Huang of the Qin Dynasty burned the history books of the Chinese people fabricated, which are characterized by historical distortions, and this is natural and righteous.
It is a natural retaliation because Chinese gaslighted the Qin-Shi-Huang as a descendant of the Chinese people, and the Qin Dynasty was also a descendant of the yi people.
Definately, Emperor Qin-Shi-Huang's ill-treatment of the Chinese is self-defense.
It is only a pity that Emperor Qin-Shi-Huang could not ill-treat the Chinese more.
In the first, your C people, who are not noble of the Zhou Dynasty, claim to be descendants of the Zhou Dynasty, revealing your people’s ugly identity.
And your Chinese immigrants immigrate to Korea and claim that the Shang people's surnames are Lee, Son, and Jeong etc. You, the same Chinese, should take responsibility for the history distortion of this Chinese Korean.
And, It is right to think that the Y haplogroup of European natives is C, and that the first dynasty in China is also C.
Xia Dynasty is a dynasty that Chinese people created in delusion. Your C-people are the right ethnic group to exclude from the normal human category, distorting history from ancient times.
You C people's value to the whole of humanity is your role as a teacher while humanity should never copy history like China’s. China are right to be recorded in a historical form that should never be copied in human history forever. Please do not convey your spirit of distortion and malice to future mankind. The historical form of your sinister, dead ethnic's malice must not be repeated in future human generations.
And isn't it your preconceived notion that humans 7000 years ago were unable to navigate through sea?
My comment :
@夜行者 And then you continue to insert O2a into history AD900 years before, but that's because you Chin-people have the same identity cancer cells that's only for immigration and reproduction.
There is a malicious spirit in the world that is right to perish. And the spirit is Chinese. They are evil in history, and they are evil in identity.
from: 아메리카 원주민과 Y-DNA Haplogroup Q의 기원. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-25. Retrieved 2023-01-25.
My comment :
It is wrong to think that Tungus speakers are the same people from ancient to modern times. Ancient Tungus and modern Tungus are genetically different. Dumb East Asia history scholars being duped by the Chinese.
from: Y -염색체 하플로그룹 O의 분포. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-11. Retrieved 2023-01-11.
My comment :
縄文：D1a2 (先住民 - チベット人と共通の祖。日本とチベットの間の南部どこかで分離。海洋活動推定。) 弥生：O1b2 (倭人 - 越人と共通の祖。中国南部の古代海洋貿易で活動。死亡率が高いので中華人に混ざらなかった。インド人とのつながり推定。) 古墳：Q1a1 (月人 - 月氏国人、初期秦人と共通の祖。アメリカ先住民で、バリング海峡または内陸から分離。誤解された偽物が多い。) ＊注意：サルが人間になったのではなく、サルと人間が共通の祖。 隋唐：O2a2 (北中華人 - 後期鮮卑族、現代北中華人の祖、現代韓国人の47%の祖、漢建国以前の定義の九夷。 認知歪曲と歴史歪曲で鮮卑族を奪取した。歴史歪曲技術と民族奪取技術が卓越な民族。 現代日本人の20%を占めるO2のうち半分以上を占める。 日本では古墳人、弥生人に偽装している。) +) 初期の鮮卑族はN1a。初期の契丹族はC2b。初期朝鮮族、初期半島韓族はC2c。モンゴル族もC2c。匈奴族はR。 C1a1は先住民の先住民。 ヨーロッパの先住民もC1。 O2a2はO-P201、O-m7(秦漢時代、中国南部に移住した北中華人)、O-m117(隋唐時代、中国西部、チベットに移住した北中華人)等で構成される。
from: 【最新DNA解析】日本人は一体どこから来たのか？「古代日本人」のルーツとは！？【ゆっくり解説】. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-16. Retrieved 2023-01-16.
Comment :
Yayoi (Korea) vs Yayoi (Japan) DNA : Brother war
My comment :
Truth: Chinese group claiming to be yayoi Korean(Lee clan joseon) vs Yayoi japanese group(japan)
Comment :
Koreans and Japanese are different and look different.
from: Imjin War - Japanese Invasion of Korea 1592-1598 - 4K DOCUMENTARY. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-20. Retrieved 2023-01-20.
My comment :
Simple. Korea’s surname system are renamed by Chinese Korean. Thats why todays K people has same last name.
My comment :
Koreans never tell the truth to Western society. Because Chinese Korean who migrated in the 7-9th century distorted Korean peninsular history.
from: Imjin War - Japanese Invasion of Korea 1592-1598 - 4K DOCUMENTARY. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-20. Retrieved 2023-01-20.
My comment :
Hello😊 I am a student from Korean Academy. I am so amazed by the similarity between word ‘Pasa’(=파사)(means true appear) and ‘Puri’(=뿌리)(means root) in Korea. Here’s what I realize : I realized that form of early Gaya kingdom’s golden crown and France’s symbol(Fleur de lis) are came from India. Also, I guess the symbol of Marundeeswar Temple had a great influence on Korea and Japan especially ‘Tomoe’ and Hata clan. In the future, I want to study Indian language and study Indo-Pacific history. Please let me know if anybody know a good way for study. Thank you for reading the comments😉
Comment (이철우):
Crowns in ancient Korea are similar to scythian's. King's DNA in Silla are closer to scythian than Hun by Chungang Uni. But Hur's DNA is Indo's.
My comment :
@이철우 아 뭐야. 짜증나게 중국인 이씨가 댓글을 쓰네? 신라인이라고 13세기에 거짓말한 경주 이씨도, 백제인이라고 21세기 거짓말하는 전주 이씨도, 이제가기 위서 창작으로 가야인이라는 인천 이씨도 모두 중국인이다. 너희 역사날조집단 중국인 이씨와는 관계가 없는 이야기이므로 널 치우고 싶구나. 무슨 염치로 댓글을 다니?
from: கொரியா மற்றும் தமிழ் தொடர்பு | Korean Tamil Queen | Seembavalam - Heo Hwang Ok | SundayDisturbers. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-20. Retrieved 2023-01-20.
Comment :
팩트: 고구려인이라고 주장하는 이씨 중국인이 세운 나라. 후기 고구려는 이 중국인 이민자들 때문에 망했다.
from:당나라 안에 나라를 세운 고구려인／【이정기下】. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-21. Retrieved 2023-01-21.
My comment :
It is wrong to think that Tungus speakers are the same people from ancient to modern times. Ancient Tungus and modern Tungus are genetically different. Dumb East Asia history scholars being duped by the Chinese.
My comment :
Classifying the Gojoseon as O2a is an error.
This video confuses the Chinese Yeon Dynasty with the Gojoseon.
Gojoseon people are descendants of the Shang people of China and are a group of Haplo C2.
This is confirmed through the genetic distribution of the family name group and region, which self-proclaimed descendants of real Gojoseon.(Chinese surnames like Lee and Chang are not Gojoseon people. These are the surnames that the Chinese things as they immigrate with historical distortions.)
Also, there was always a death threat to ancient maritime activities, and only groups with blood-related and religious connections could use ships. The O2a group, which is not maritime culture at all, cannot move with the O1b group of maritime culture.
Today, more than half of Japan's 20%of O2a is dominated by the Chinese Tang Dynasty's O-m117, indicating that O2a's migration to the Korean Peninsula and Japan is during the Tang Dynasty (7th-9th century).
Today, O2a is distorted in history as Yayoi, Kofun, Gojoseon, Korean. It is the traditional method of the Chinese people that has continued since ancient times.
from: Y -염색체 하플로그룹 O의 분포. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-11. Retrieved 2023-01-11.
Comment (Failed Indonesian Painter):
Wow, I tought japanese, koreans and chinese is in one subgroup, but look like japanese and koreans more closer to southeast asians
Comment (GeoNomad):
Southeast Asians and East Asians are very similar historically.
Comment (Parisan 99):
Korea n and Japanese men came from Vat Komnou in Cambodia
Comment (gg8964):
@Hwasia Qhan don't forger southeast asia have 90% O2a
Comment (Hwasia Qhan):
@gg8964 Not sure if it’s 90% but yes East and South East Asian are closest in terms of Y DNA, much like Northern European and Southern European.
Comment (山田次郎):
It says that when Baekje and Goguryeo collapsed, a large number of refugees came to Japan and became naturalized, so I think 20% of them are people from that time.
Comment (Marasujan):
@GeoNomad Still no O2b human bones found in ancient Yangtze River civilization tombs. Therefore, it cannot be said that O2b is the main body of the ancient Yangtze River civilization. And The oldest R144 in O2b is found in Jeju Island. It is not found in ancient Yangtze River ancient tomb human bones. In most ancient Yangtze River tombs, only O2a O3 O1 are found. The highest frequency is O1. So, the main body of the Yangtze River civilization is O1. And it has not yet been proven that O2b came from the Yangtze River, so many scholars have only hypothesized and conjectured, but there is no clear evidence. It is true that O2b probably came from around China during the Ice Age (N also from south to north), but it was not settled in China, and it seems to have been around the Yellow River region and Jeju Island.
Comment (Marasujan):
@GeoNomad By your logic, N is also East Asian and Southeast Asian siblings.
My comment :
There was always a death threat to ancient maritime activities, and only groups with blood-related and religious connections could use ships. The O2a group, which is not maritime culture at all, cannot move with the O1b group of marine culture. Today, more than half of Japan's 20% of O2a is dominated by the Chinese Tang Dynasty's O-m117, indicating that O2a's migration to the Korean Peninsula and Japan is during the Tang Dynasty (7th-9th century).
Comment (山田次郎):
The O2 group in Japan is a Northern Han refugee group from the Han Dynasty, Baekje and Silla.
The Tang Dynasty was ruled by the northern nomadic tribe C lineage.
My comment :
@山田次郎 Not at all.
Yuwen(宇文), the first Xianbei(鮮卑) clan, called themself a member of Zhou royal family.
The mythological element is also consistent with the Zhou, beihu(北胡).
With a high probability, the early Xianbei was the Haplo N1a group, and the Haplo O2a group took the Xianbei ethnic through historical distortion.
47% of Koreans were the O2a group, and it is estimated that ethnic change occurred through historical distortion,
and the Qin Dynasty was also ethnic change into the O2a group in the late period.
Ethnic change by the O2a group is a very common phenomenon in ancient East Asian History.
from: Y -염색체 하플로그룹 O의 분포. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-25. Retrieved 2023-01-25.
Comment (47zM128):
i heard two of four samples found in the Lower Xiajiadian Culture their downstreams are belonged to O2a1b-F238 and N1b each, and there is a O2a2a-FGC50558 sample found in neolithic age past human bones from the Ando, Yeosu-si, South Jeolla Province, and there are a few samples of O2a2a-FGC50558 and O1b2-L682 found in three kingdom period past human bones from Yuha-ri/Daesung-dong, Gimhae-si, South Kyeongsang Province, Korean peninsula, according to studies 2021~22.
Comment (GeoNomad):
Thanks for the interesting information. Can you link to the related article information?
Comment (47zM128):
Northeastern Asian and Jomon-related genetic structure in the Three Kingdoms period of Gimhae, Korea
Comment (47zM128):
terminal marker searching is based on with genomic viewer or bam file attached by ebi, hgdp, kpgp
My comment :
The data I read is a paper that jomon gene D1a2 and yayoi gene O1b2 was found. Are you sure you read the same paper as me? Or, Are you now distorting genetic data because you are afraid that the Chinese's historical distortion of "ancient Koreans are O2a" will turn out to be lies?
Aren't you a troll who deliberately uses the name 47zM128? Are you trying to trick people?
Comment (47zM128):
좀 가라. 머릿속에 들어가는 모든 정보가 정치 역사로 밖에 호환 안되는 거 같은데.
My comment :
@47zM128 웃기네ㅋㅋ 중국계 한국인놈. 여기서도 역사날조를 하고있네. 여기서는 위서 '환단고기'를 한국의 정식 교과서로 사용해야한다고 주장 안 해? 여기서도 공자는 한국인의 후손이라고 주장해봐ㅋㅋ. 정신나간 중국인 이민자가 여기서는 정상인인척 위장하네😂
My comment :
@GeoNomad If you're curious about the identity of these crazy Koreans,
search ‘Kongzu Korean’
or search ‘중국인 시조, 한국인이라는 빼박증거 있다... 중국 박물관에도 전시’
from: Y -염색체 하플로그룹 O의 분포. Youtube. Archived from the original on 2023-01-25. Retrieved 2023-01-25.
(...)
당신은 영화 장면에 어떠한 주관적인 이면성을 가지고 있지 않은 감독임을 잊지 말라.
모든 영화 장면에는 정해진 “씬 넘버”(Scene Number)가 있다.
90분짜리 영화는 약 120개 내외의 씬으로 구성되어 있다.
감독은 한순간에 하나의 씬는 밖에 촬영할 수 없다.
영화:타이타닉 초반, 디카프리오가 아름다운 여주인공을 스케치하는 #12 씬과 후반에 타이타닉이 침몰당하는 #100 씬을 동시에 찍는 것은 불가능하다.
하지만 감독이 #12 씬을 찍는 동안 #100 씬을 생각하고, #30 씬을 찍는 동안 # 120 씬을 생각하고 있다면 어떻게 될까? 감독이 촬영 중이라는 사실을 잊고 악역에게 화를 내고 본인이 주인공 배역으로 착각하여 흐느끼며 울고 있다면 어떨까?
타이타닉이 아닌 영화 전체가 침몰하게 될 것이다. 해당 영화의 그 어떤 한 장면도 제대로 찍힌 장면이 없을 것이다.
120개의 씬으로 구성된 완벽한 영화는 120개의 완벽한 씬으로 구성되어 있다. 하나하나의 모든 장면의 촬영 순간마다 감독이 “현존”을 하며 그 장면에 아름다움을 담아야 한다. 그렇게 120개의 “현존”이라는 장면들이 모여 “아름다운 인생”이라는 영화가 완성된다. 그 어떤 감독도 #120 씬을 위해 #30 씬의 퀄리티를 희생해야 한다”고 말하지 않는다. 영화에 있어서는 잔잔한 도입부의 장면과 클라이맥스 장면, 모두 동등하게 중요하다.
음악도 마찬가지다. 어떤 지휘자가 교향곡의 클라이맥스를 위해 도입부의 퀄리티를 희생하겠는가?
지각 세계에 잠들어 있다면 미래를 위해 현재를 포기하는 경향이 있다. 그들이 찍고 있는 영화는 몰락하고 있는 삼류 영화일 뿐이다. 보았는가? 세상은 코미디다. (...)
My comment :
감사합니다. 덕분에 침전해있고 우울하던 지금 정신이 잘못되었다는 것을 알았습니다.
from: Archived from the original on 2023-01-29. Retrieved 2023-01-29.
Comments
Post a Comment